- Free Consultation: 401-552-5000 Tap Here To Call Us
What Is A Diminished Value Claim In Massachusetts?

Key Takeaways
An accident can lower your car’s resale value, even after repairs; Massachusetts law and insurance policy terms affect whether you can claim this loss. Proper records and an independent appraisal can help support your claim.
- Repaired cars may still lose resale value.
- Accident history can affect market value.
- Massachusetts insurance policies differ in coverage.
- Appraisals can help prove diminished value.
- Keep repair records and accident evidence.
A repaired car can still lose resale value. In Massachusetts you generally can’t recover that loss from your own insurer, but you may be able to claim it from the at-fault driver or their insurer, depending on the policy that covers them.
It is important to note that just because you have paid to repair your car doesn’t mean it will have a full market value again. If someone checks the history of your car they may offer less. Even if the repairs have been carried out correctly.
What is Diminished Value?
Diminished value is the difference between your car’s market value immediately before the accident and its market value after it has been fully repaired.
An example could be having a fairly new car with no history of any accidents. A driver has a collision with your car, and the at-fault driver’s insurer pays for the repairs. The car now looks as good as new. However, if someone checks the vehicle history report, they will see that it was involved in an accident. The car is now looking as good as new; however, if someone were to look at the car history report they will see there has been an accident.
This could mean they are willing to pay less for the car than if it had no history of any accidents.
This is known as Inherent Diminished Value.
Inherent Diminished Value is not the same as general depreciation of vehicles. All cars will generally reduce in value over time as they age and get more miles on the odometer. A claim for Diminished Value is about the extra loss in value due to the accident and repairs.
Why Would a Repaired Vehicle Have Decreased Value?
Even if a vehicle has been repaired there may still be some financial impact.
Some customers may be worried about:
- History – The vehicle history report will show that the vehicle had an accident.
- Damage – If the accident caused damage to the frame or other damage to the vehicle it may put customers off.
- Replacement Parts – Customers may have concerns about the standard of replacement parts.
- Quality – There may be concerns about the quality of the repair, paint match and/or any hidden damage.
- Negotiation – The customer may use the accident history to negotiate a lower price.
Not every accident will result in decreased value. The age, mileage, previous condition, type of damage and quality of repair all play a part in how much the vehicle is worth on the market.
Can You File a Diminished Value Claim in Massachusetts?
It depends on whose insurance you are claiming against.
Your own insurer: Generally no. The Supreme Judicial Court held in 2003 that diminished value isn’t covered under the collision part of the standard policy (Given v. Commerce Insurance).
The at-fault driver’s insurer: It depends on the policy edition. In McGilloway v. Safety Insurance (2021), the court held diminished value is recoverable, if adequately proved, under the 2008 standard policy. In Cubberley v. Commerce Insurance (January 30, 2025), the court held the 2016 standard policy excludes it, so insurers on that edition aren’t required to pay it.
NOTE: For obtaining further information regarding the above-mentioned policy you may refer to the official document: McGilloway v. Safety Insurance Co., 488 Mass. 610 (2021).
What If the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Refuses to Pay?
An insurer’s refusal to pay doesn’t necessarily mean the at-fault driver isn’t legally responsible for the loss in value.
The insurance company’s coverage decision and the at-fault driver’s potential legal responsibility are separate issues. Whether you have another option for recovering diminished value will depend on the circumstances and applicable law.
If the insurer refuses, ask which policy edition applies and why it is refusing, and gather the evidence of lost market value.
How Do You Prove a Diminished Value Claim?
Evidence will be required to demonstrate that the accident has led to a reduction in the value of your vehicle.
In McGilloway, the court said diminished value is recoverable if it is adequately proved. In practice, that means showing the accident caused the loss and putting a dollar figure on it. Being in an accident isn’t enough on its own.
Some useful documents to look for could include:
- Proof of purchase of the vehicle.
- Proof of pre-accident valuation.
- The police accident report.
- Photos of the damage.
- Repair quotes and final repair invoices.
- Proof of parts changed and any structural repairs.
- Vehicle history reports.
- Diminished value report from a professional.
This will help to show exactly what happened to your vehicle and whether it has been restored to its market value. Reach out to a Massachusetts car accident lawyer for legal guidance.
Can a Diminished Value Calculator Estimate Your Car’s Loss?
You can use a Diminished Value Calculator to get an estimate of how much your car may have lost in value due to the accident. This will generally take into account factors such as the age, miles and current condition of the vehicle, as well as the repair costs. However, this will just be an estimate.
What Is a Diminished Value Appraisal?
It is a professional assessment of how much the market value of your vehicle has dropped after the accident. This may take into account the vehicle’s actual cash value prior to the collision, the history of any damage, the repair history and similar vehicle sales. This can be used to back up your property damage claim.
As the appraisal from your insurance company may differ to that of an independent appraisal, you should understand how they have decided on the value of your vehicle after repairs.
What Factors Affect Your Vehicle’s Diminished Value?
There is no set percentage of diminished value. It will depend on what your vehicle is and what damage has been done.
Several factors could impact on the value:
- Age and Mileage – Newer vehicles with low mileage may be worth more than an older vehicle with high mileage.
- Pre-Existing Condition – A vehicle in excellent condition prior to the accident could be worth more than one which has pre-existing damage or mechanical issues.
- Type Of Damage – If your vehicle has structural, frame or major component damage this may cause more concern to future buyers than just small cosmetic damage.
- Repairs – How much repair work has been done, what parts have been used and how much information is available could impact on how the buyer sees the vehicle.
- Demand – The make/model, how many are available and the local second hand car market can impact on how much it is worth.
The aim is to determine how much you have lost due to the accident rather than normal depreciation.
What Should You Do If Your Car’s Resale Value Has Dropped After an Accident?
Collecting documentation can help if you think you have lost value.
Begin by gathering together your accident report, photos, repair invoices and vehicle history details. Ask the at-fault driver’s insurer which policy applies and what its position is on diminished value.
Check if there was any mention of reduced value in the settlement if they have paid for repairs.
Be careful when signing off on the final property damage release. You should make sure you understand what is being released and if you are releasing any residual value claims. If your car was totaled instead of repaired, here’s what you should know.
If your claim is being challenged by the insurance company then you can seek help from an attorney. They can help you understand what evidence you have, what the policy says and what options you may have.
Not sure which policy applies to your claim? Call Tapalian Law at 401-552-5000 for a free consultation
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a vehicle with an accident history have a reduced resale value?
Potentially. However the amount of money you could get for your car will depend on how much damage was done in the collision. If there was significant or structural damage then some buyers may pay less.
Can I make a diminished value claim if repairs have been carried out?
Even if your car has been repaired you may still be able to claim for reduced value. This will depend on proving that your car still has a reduced value as a result of the accident.
Will I need an appraisal to make a diminished value claim?
While you will not always need an appraisal, getting one can help. A good appraisal will detail how you calculated the value of your vehicle and include evidence to back up the loss you have estimated.
Can I make a reduced value claim if the other driver did not have insurance?
Even if the other driver doesn’t have insurance they may still be responsible personally. It may be harder to get any compensation but what options you have will depend on the circumstances and any cover they may have.
Can I claim diminished value from my own insurance in Massachusetts?
Generally no. The Supreme Judicial Court has held that diminished value isn’t covered under the collision part of the standard Massachusetts auto policy. A claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer is a separate question and depends on the policy edition.







